I tried three MLMs. Not one. Three. Young Living Essential Oils, Younique, and Doterra. I spent real money on all of them. I spent real time on all of them. Here is everything, with numbers.
The scorecard
Young Living Essential Oils
Young Living was first. I ordered the starter kit and spent weeks being bounced around by customer service — calls that went nowhere, follow-ups that disappeared. I eventually got a response only after filing a complaint through the Better Business Bureau.
"I had to file a BBB complaint just to get someone to respond. I was trying to give them money. That was the customer service experience before I'd even started."
Before I had a real chance to build anything, the experience of trying to deal with the company itself burned me out on it. When your distributor journey starts with a BBB complaint, that's information.
Younique
Nine months. Consistent posting, videos, team calls, building relationships. I made roughly what I put in. Not profit — breakeven. And that's before counting what nine months of those skills applied elsewhere would have been worth.
The product was fine. The community was genuinely warm. But the math on MLM compensation structures doesn't work for the vast majority of participants, and I was in the vast majority.
The skills I developed — content creation, showing up consistently on social media, talking about products in a way that felt natural — those were real. The business model just wasn't a good vehicle for them.
Doterra
After Younique I decided I just hadn't tried hard enough. So I went all in on Doterra — a full year, genuinely all in. Spent ~$1,165. Made ~$800. Net: -$365. Plus a year of time that won't come back.
"After Younique I thought I just hadn't tried hard enough. So I went all in on Doterra. Net result: -$365 plus twelve months of my life. The problem wasn't my effort level."
This is the part I want to be honest about. I didn't fail at Doterra because I quit too early or didn't work hard enough. I gave it everything I had. The problem wasn't my effort level — it was the math of the model itself.
What I'd do instead
Everything I was doing during my MLM years — content creation, audience building, talking authentically about products — translates directly to affiliate marketing. One critical difference: you keep what you earn, there's no monthly auto-ship requirement, and the structure doesn't require you to recruit anyone.
The skills transfer. The math is better.
If you're considering an MLM right now, I'm not here to tell you it can't work. Some people do make money. But I'd ask you to look at the income disclosure statement for the specific company — they're required to publish them — and look at what the median distributor actually earns after expenses. That number will tell you more than any upline presentation.
The combined total
Across three MLMs, 2+ years of genuine effort:
Those years weren't wasted — I learned a lot about consistency, about talking to people, about what I'm actually good at. But the vehicle was wrong. Same energy, better vehicle, different result.
That's the whole lesson.
Did you try an MLM? I'd genuinely like to know how it went — the real numbers, not the highlight reel. Hit reply if you got this by email or drop a comment below.
Leave a comment